No I completely agree with you. But this will get closed cause soon as an admin answers the thread, he closes it. :(
I've never done 140k without broken pve trinkets (ok I did 300k in s14 on here xD), but it was possible to get 140k (not in duels, but I saw Kalimist do 150k once, but that was the most luck ever.)
On retail it was fully possible to do 100k+ Eviscerate during procs & cooldowns, infact, look at this video
go to 3:20
That was 5.4.2 aka s14 and without trinkets. So if you see rogues do 150k+ on here, it's simply because of broken pve trinkets (or they fixed this? Idk lol)
_______________________________________
But I hope this thread can stay clean and not get locked in 20 minutes due to silly arguements.