In case you haven't noticed, the thread starter made this thread to bring awareness about other people which have different proof about the formula / the way "warrior" class should work. (The seasoned soldier / and their damage, etc)
http://forum.pandawow.ru/showthread.php?t=215207&page=4&p=1285600&viewfull=1#post1285600 / http://forum.pandawow.ru/showthread.php?t=215207
So i don't see what you mean by "He got no proofs"
And the reason why im not closing this at the moment is to see other's opinion about it, since both Milorad's and the guy who made the report in Russian section, have valid points.
(This is a general discussion after all, isn't it?)