Halta

Wish I could read russian so I wouldn't waste my time :( The report you linked seems to be correct according to Google Translate, so I suppose this thread can be closed.

=====

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=103103 (Malefic Grasp) 2. Problem: The damage is too high, probably due to a wrong formula. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula (source): [b]Whole duration: 564 (+ 52.8% of Spell power) Shadow damage over 4 sec[/b] Individual ticks: (141 (+ 13.2% of Spell power) 4. Date: 5/20/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 7/10 Testing Full duration formula (source): 564 (+ 52.8% of Spell power) Data: http://i.imgur.com/3Mz17ca.png Calculations: Expected damage: 5,587 9,514 * 0.528 = 5,023.392 5,023.392 + 564 = 5,587.392 Results: The full duration should be 5,587 damage. On Pwow it's 8,172 damage. [spoiler=Recount]http://i.imgur.com/1A7Eg4P.png

http://wow.gamepedia.com/Channeling http://i.imgur.com/BPVDi98.png

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=108280 (Healing Tide Totem) 2. Problem: It heals for a LOT more than expected, probably due to a wrong formula, and it's not a static number. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula for every tick (source): 4932 (+ 48.4% of Spell power)Every tick should be a static number, there's no range. 4. Date: 5/20/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 9/10 Testing Healing Tide tick formula: (source) 4932 (+ 48.4% of Spell power) Data: 8,836 SP 9.77% PvP Power 50% purification (for totems) (mastery is irrelevant as I did this test with full hp) Calculations: Expected ticks: 15,162 8,836 * 0.484 = 4,276.624 4,276.624 + 4,932 = 9,208.624 9,208.624 * 1.0977 = 10,108.3065648 10,108.3065648 * 1.5 = 15,162.491763 Results: The expected tick is 15,162. On PandaWoW it's min18,964 avg19,455 max20,439 [spoiler=Recount]http://i.imgur.com/fS1Js5a.png

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=5394 (Healing Stream Totem) 2. Problem: It double dips from http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=16213 (Purification), from both the 25% and 50% part. 3. How it should work: It should only benefit from the 50% totem part of Purification. 4. Date: 5/20/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 9/10 7. Proof: You can see here that totems are not mentioned on the 25% part, they're their own category at Effect #3. [spoiler=Wowhead screenshot]http://i.imgur.com/CjgN5ov.png Testing Healing stream tick formula: (source) Spell power * 0.444 Data: 8,565 SP 9.77% PvP Power 50% purification (for totems) (mastery is irrelevant as I did this test with full hp) No http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=147074 (Rushing Streams) talent Calculations: Expected ticks: 6,261 8,565 * 0.444 = 3,802.86 3,802.86 * 1.0977 = 4,174.399422 4,174.399422 * 1.5 = 6,261.599133 Results: The expected tick is 6,261. On PandaWoW it's 7,824, because it double dips from Purification: 6,261 * 1.25 = 7,826 [spoiler=Recount]http://i.imgur.com/2960YHF.png

I saw gateway video in a thread but I don't remember where. You guys talked about how it's a visual bug that the green gateway is sideways. This is not actually a bug, you shouldn't waste time trying to fix it. Here's a retail video where the same happens: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/47590818?t=15m44s Just thought I'd mention it here.

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=76669 (Mastery: Illuminated Healing) 2. Problem: Mastery shields from heals are lower than they should be, because the mastery converts down to an integer. Example: If I have 23.79% mastery, my shields will only count as 23%. 3. How it should work: The shields generated from mastery should be loyal to your mastery value and not get converted down to an integer. 4. Date: 5/18/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 6/10 By default, the Mastery value is 10%, so any heal should also add a 10% shield. This works fine: [spoiler=Holy Shock –– 10% Mastery –– 11,415 heal | 1,141 shield | 1,141 expected]http://i.imgur.com/DEx2uNF.png Once it turns into a rational, at e.g. 23.79%, you get lower shields than you should: [spoiler=Holy Shock –– 23.79% Mastery –– 80,831 heal | 18,591 shield | 19,229 expected]http://i.imgur.com/Dt72BnE.png You can easily check this for yourself by doing HealValue * 0.mastery = ShieldValue.

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=142535 (Spirit of Conquest) 2. Problem: The enchant gives 750 spirit whenever it procs, regardless of your mana %. 3. How it should work: It should only give spirit if your mana was less than 25% at the time of the proc. 4. Date: 5/16/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 7/10 7. Footage: https://gyazo.com/a1f5d447511e31cdc0960ddce8659ada

Updated with ingame footage.

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=44203 (Tranquility) 2. Problems: The tranquility "main" channeled heal is benefitting from both direct&hot components of Rdruid Mastery (http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=77495). It also procs mastery as if it was a direct heal. 3. How it should work: It should only benefit from the HoT portion of the Mastery, not the direct too. It's not a direct heal. It should not proc mastery, as it is a HoT. Only direct spells can proc mastery. 4. Date: 5/15/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 8.5/10 7. Proof: You can see here that the direct portion only increases these heals:[spoiler=Wowhead screenshot for Mastery: Harmony]http://i.imgur.com/ivzLCpp.png That also means that only these direct heals should proc the mastery HoT buff, which Tranquility should benefit from.[spoiler=Wowhead screenshot for the Harmony buff]http://i.imgur.com/iqyJqiE.png Lastly, in this retail video, Tranquility is used, but it's not refreshing his Harmory buff, because only direct heals should. --- Testing --- Tranquility "main" heal formula (source): 9037 (+ 83.5% of Spell power) Data: 1531 sp 6.05% pvppower 10% naturalist passive 10% mastery Calculations: Expected ticks (without Harmony HoT buff): 12,033 1531 * 0.835 = 1,278.385 1,278.385 + 9,037 = 10,315.385 10,315.385 * 1.0605 = 10,919.4657925 10,919.4657925 * 1.1 = 12,033.41237175 ^ = naturalist Expected ticks (with Harmony HoT buff): 13,236 12,033 * 1.1 = 13,236.753608925 ^ = mastery Results: On Pandawow, the main heal of tranquility wrongly double dips from the direct mastery portion, and also procs mastery. Expected ticks (without mastery buff procced): 12,033 -> 12,033 -> 12,033 -> 12,033 Pwow: 13,236 -> (then it wrongly procs mastery) -> 14,559 -> 14,559 -> 14,559

Perhaps you don't understand how gear scaling works. It scales more with full gear, but not that much, hence why it's only a 3/10.

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=48438 (Wild Growth) 2. Problem: The overall healing is a bit less than expected. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula: 6930 [+ 64.4% of Spell power] over 7 sec 4. Date: 5/15/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 3/10 7. Source: https://web-beta.archive.org/web/20130903140140/http://www.db.pandawow.me?spell=48438/wild-growth#comments ––– Testing ––– Formula 6930 [+ 64.4% of Spell power] Data 1531 SP 6.05% pvppower 10% naturalist passive Calculation Expected healing over 7 sec: 9,234 1531 * 0.644 = 985.964 985.964 + 6930 = 7,915.964 7,915.964 * 1.1 = 8,707.5604 8,707.5604 * 1.0605 = 9,234.3678042 Results The expected healing is 9,234. On PandaWoW it heals for 9,226 everytime. [spoiler=Recount]http://i.imgur.com/rgEJn7U.png

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=44203 (Tranquility) 2. Problem: The tranquility small HoT buff heals for more than expected. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula: 1542 (+ 14.2% of Spell power) 4. Date: 5/15/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 6.5/10 7. Source: https://web-beta.archive.org/web/20140218002043/http://wowhead.com:80/spell=44203 ––– Testing ––– HoT formula 1542 (+ 14.2% of Spell power) Data 1531 SP 6.05% pvppower 10% mastery 10% naturalist passive Calculation 1st stack: 2257 1531 * 0.142 = 217.402 217.402 + 1542 = 1,759.402 1,759.402 * 1.0605 = 1,865.845821 1,865.845821 * 1.1 = 2,052.4304031 2,052.4304031 * 1.1 = 2,257.67344341 2nd stack: 4,515 2,257.67344341 * 2 = 4,515.34688682 3rd stack+: 6,773 2,257.67344341 * 3 = 6,773.02033023 Results So the expected tick values are 2,257/4,515/6,773/6,773 and so on. On PandaWoW it heals for 2,272/4,546/6,819/6,819 and so on. https://gyazo.com/a9228de5c143c3b250f68a2120c25ea7 This might not seem like a big difference, but it scales a lot with full gear.

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=19750 (Flash of Light) 2. Problem: The healing is low, due to an incorrect formula most likely. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula: 11882-13331 + 112% of SP 4. Date: 5/14/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 7/10 7. Source: https://paladiner.wordpress.com/in-depth-holy-paladin-guide/ ------- Testing ------- Formula 11882-13331 + 112% of SP Data 34,650 Spellpower 55.54% PvP Power 5% Seal of Insight 25% Holy Insight 100 non-crit Flash of Lights Calculations Expected highest: 106,439 [spoiler=Highest]34,650 * 1.12 = 38,808 38,808 + 13331 = 52,139 52,139 * 1.5554 = 81,097.0006 81,097.0006 * 1.05 = 85,151.85063 85,151.85063 * 1.25 = 106,439.8132875 Expected lowest: 103,481 [spoiler=Lowest]34,650 * 1.12 = 38,808 38,808 + 11882 = 50,690 50,690 * 1.5554 = 78,843.226 78,843.226 * 1.05 = 82,785.3873 82,785.3873 * 1.25 = 103,481.734125 Results So the expected numbers are 103,481 to 106,439. On PandaWoW it heals for lower, at a 102,508 to 105,349. [spoiler=Recount]http://i.imgur.com/FrGXHgz.png

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=635 (Divine Light) 2. Problem: The healing is low, due to an incorrect formula most likely. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula: 8390-9346 + 78.5% of SP 4. Date: 5/14/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 7/10 7. Source: https://paladiner.wordpress.com/in-depth-holy-paladin-guide/ ------- Testing ------- Formula 8390-9346 + 78.5% of SP Data 34,650 Spellpower 55.54% PvP Power 5% Seal of Insight 25% Holy Insight 100 non-crit Holy Lights Calculations Expected highest: 74,607 [spoiler=Highest]34,650 * 0.785 = 27,200.25 27,200.25 + 9346 = 36,546.25 36,546.25 * 1.5554 = 56,844.03725 56,844.03725 * 1.05 = 59,686.2391125 59,686.2391125 * 1.25 = 74,607.798890625 Expected lowest: 72,656 [spoiler=Lowest]34,650 * 0.785 = 27,200.25 27,200.25 + 8390 = 35,590.25 35,590.25 * 1.5554 = 55,357.07485 55,357.07485 * 1.05 = 58,124.9285925 58,124.9285925 * 1.25 = 72,656.160740625 Results So the expected numbers are 72,656 to 74,607. On PandaWoW it heals for lower, at a 71,980 to 73,895. [spoiler=Recount]http://i.imgur.com/mJcZK77.png

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=82326 (Divine Light) 2. Problem: The healing is too low, due to an incorrect formula most likely. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula: 15910-17725 +149% of SP 4. Date: 5/14/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 8.5/10 7. Source: https://paladiner.wordpress.com/in-depth-holy-paladin-guide/ ------- Testing ------- Formula 15910-17725 +149% of SP Data 34,650 Spellpower 55.54% PvP Power 5% Seal of Insight 25% Holy Insight 100 non-crit Divine Lights Calculations Expected highest: 141,582 [spoiler=Highest]34,650 * 1.49 = 51,628.5 51,628.5 + 17,725 = 69,353.5 69,353.5 * 1.5554 = 107,872.4339 107,872.4339 * 1.05 = 113,266.055595 113,266.055595 * 1.25 = 141,582.56949375 Expected lowest: 137,877 [spoiler=Lowest]34,650 * 1.49 = 51,628.5 51,628.5 + 15,910 = 67,538.5 67,538.5 * 1.5554 = 105,049.3829 105,049.3829 * 1.05 = 110,301.852045 110,301.852045 * 1.25 = 137,877.31505625 Results So the expected numbers are 137,877 to 141,582. On PandaWoW it heals for much lower, at a 126,252 to 129,896. [spoiler=Recount]http://i.imgur.com/1xUwpEz.png

1. Names: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=114917 (Stay of Execution) 2. Problem: When dispelled, the heal is too weak. 3. How it should work: Once your Stay of Execution gets dispelled, it should heal for (5 * most recent tick), in this case 5 * 7856 = 39,280. In the gif it heals for 31,711. 4. Date: 5/14/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 7/10 7. Source: http://wow.gamepedia.com/Execution_Sentence 8. In-game footage: https://gyazo.com/c5002fb0a55d68d1b740d039633ef4b7

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=20473 (Holy Shock) 2. Problem: The healing is too low, probably because of a wrong formula. 3. How it should work: This is the correct formula: 9014-9764 + 83.3% of Spellpower 4. Date: 5/12/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 7.5/10 7. Source: https://paladiner.wordpress.com/in-depth-holy-paladin-guide/ ------- Testing ------- Healing Formula 9014-9764 + 83.3% of Spellpower Data I worked with: 3,849 Spellpower 5.07% PvP Power 5% Seal of Insight 25% Holy Insight (healer passive) 10% 2set bonus Calculations: Expected highest: 19,675 [spoiler=Calculations for Highest:] 3,849 * 0.833 = 3,206.217 3,206.217 + 9764 = 12,970.217 12,970.217 * 1.0507 = 13,627.8070019 13,627.8070019 * 1.05 = 14,309.197351995 14,309.197351995 * 1.25 = 17,886.49668999375 17,886.49668999375 * 1.1 = 19,675.14635899313 Expected lowest: 18,537 [spoiler=Calculations for Lowest:] 3,849 * 0.833 = 3,206.217 3,206.217 + 9014 = 12,220.217 12,220.217 * 1.0507 = 12,839.7820019 12,839.7820019 * 1.05 = 13,481.771101995 13,481.771101995 * 1.25 = 16,852.21387749375 16,852.21387749375 * 1.1 = 18,537.43526524313 Results/Comparison: I did 150 non-crit Holy Shocks on both Warmane and Pandawow to compare. [spoiler=Warmane] On Warmane it works as expected, with a min of 18538 and a max of 19670, extremely loyal to the formula. http://i.imgur.com/cIp0rdH.png [spoiler=PandaWoW Fun] On PandaWoW the formula is off, resulting in lower healing. Min: 17976 / Max: 19069 http://i.imgur.com/WR5zyZe.png

Updated the priority, as I just also found out that casts made with Purpose do not have a 25% chance to reproc Purpose, which is a HUGE nerf. Tested with about 50 procs, none reprocced itself.

1. Names: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=54957 (Glyph of Flash of Light) 2. Problem: When your target has the Glyph of Flash of Light buff up, it does not get consumed to increase the healing of these heals by 10%: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=114917 (Stay of Execution) http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=53652 (Beacon of Light) http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=633 (Lay on Hands) 3. How it should work: After casting any of those heals on a target with your Glyph of FoL buff, the buff should be consumed and their healing should be increased by 10%. 4. Date: 5/11/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 6.5/10 7. Source: https://web-beta.archive.org/web/20140601163316/http://www.wowhead.com:80/spell=54957/glyph-of-flash-of-light#modifies 8. In-game footage: Stay of Execution Beacon of Light Lay on Hands

Yeah that too, but the damage that consumed it is not reduced by 40%, so that part is not working either.

https://gyazo.com/582c98374d0011329ed653fdf5074ae7

1. Name: http://db.pandawow.me/?spell=117012 2. Problem: When using the talented Unleash with Rockbitter Weapon, there's no 40% damage reduction from the enemy it was used on, and the buff disappears with the first attack on the shaman. 3. How it should work: After unleashing an enemy with Rockbitter Weapon, they should deal 40% less damage to the shaman and this buff should last for 5 seconds, not consumed instantly. 4. Date: 5/10/2017 5. Realm: Fun 6. Priority: 7/10 https://gyazo.com/582c98374d0011329ed653fdf5074ae7